Rancid olive oil is most easily identified by its smell and taste: rancid oil smells stale or waxy, and its taste is flat, pungent, or cardboard-like. Fresh extra virgin olive oil, on the other hand, smells fruity and fresh grassy. Rancidity degrades both taste and nutritional value, so it's worth recognizing the differences.

Oxidized olive oil smells and tastes rancid.

Rancid olive oil smells musty, waxy, or like old nuts. The taste is flat or sharp, and the fruity and peppery notes of fresh extra virgin olive oil are completely absent. If the oil has virtually no smell or taste, that also indicates a decline in quality.

The easiest test: pour a small amount into a glass and smell it. Fresh, high-quality extra virgin olive oil smells like green olives or freshly cut grass. These fresh aromas are gone from rancid oil. The taste test confirms what your sense of smell tells you – fresh oil should taste fruity and leave a slight peppery burn in your throat.

How does appearance reveal rancidity?

Appearance alone does not indicate quality as reliably as smell and taste, but certain changes can suggest a problem. Color alone does not indicate quality – the shade of olive oil naturally varies from greenish-gold to yellow depending on the variety and ripeness.

Olive oil stored in the cold can become cloudy and crystallize – this is completely normal and it will return to normal at room temperature.

Why does olive oil go rancid?

Olive oil goes rancid as a result of oxidation: fatty acids react with oxygen to form compounds with an unpleasant odor and taste. This is not, therefore, spoilage caused by microbes, but rather a chemical oxidation reaction. Three factors accelerate the process: light, heat, and oxygen.

Sunlight and UV radiation accelerate oxidation, which is why high-quality oils are packaged in dark bottles. Heat has the same effect—oil stored next to the stove goes rancid faster than oil kept in a cool cabinet. Every time you open the bottle, the oil is exposed to oxygen, and the process accelerates.

Cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil naturally contains polyphenols, which act as antioxidants and slow down oxidation. Therefore, it typically retains its freshness longer than more highly processed oils.

How is olive oil stored correctly?

Keep the oil in a cool, dark place and tightly sealed. In practice, this means a closed cabinet away from the stove and the window.

Olive oil is not wine that improves with age. It is best when fresh.

Can rancid olive oil be used?

Oil that has gone slightly rancid is not harmful to your health, but it has an unpleasant taste and has lost most of its beneficial compounds. Oil that is clearly rancid should be discarded. Rancid oil can be put to other uses—such as treating wooden surfaces or lubricating hinges—but it no longer serves its purpose in the kitchen.

The best way to prevent rancidity is to choose high-quality cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil, which naturally contains polyphenols. Memmas Knossos extra virgin olive oil is pressed from fresh Cretan Koroneiki olives using mechanical methods and without chemicals—the oil’s natural antioxidant content helps ensure a long shelf life.

Explore our cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil Yes Frequently asked questions about olive oil.